DaimlerChrysler Reacts Sharply to Discount Claims |
Publication | Business Day |
Date | 2001-07-03 |
Reporter | Sapa |
Web Link | www.bday.co.za |
DaimlerChrysler South
Africa (DCSA) has reacted sharply to a newspaper report naming "VIPs"
who received discounted cars bought from it by the European Aeronautic Defence
and Space Company (EADS).
EADS, a conglomerate
of German, Spanish and French companies, is involved in an arms deal with the
South African government. DCSA is a subsidiary of DaimlerChrysler AG, a German
company which holds shares in EADS.
"The DCSA and its
associate companies always had and always would operate strictly within the law.
This co-operation will continue without reservation," a statement said.
In the context of the
three-body probe into South Africa's multi-billion rand arms deal, this meant
"full and wholehearted co-operation with the duly mandated
authorities".
On Monday, the
Independent newspaper group published a list of names of 33 "VIPs" who
bought cars at a discounted rate from DCSA via EADS.
Only the surnames of
the beneficiaries were printed, but appeared to include African National
Congress chief whip Tony Yengeni, SA National Defence Force chief General
Siphiwe Nyanda and former Gauteng premier Tokyo Sexwale.
Discounts on the cars
ranged from 3,28% to 47,83%.
DCSA's statement said
the company had been the subject of "untruths and distorted, relentless,
and nakedly aggressive reporting in recent weeks".
This
"unwarranted" attack from a minority in the media had
"gratuitously" damaged South African economic and political interests
internationally, it said.
DaimlerChrysler and
EADS were separate companies worldwide.
"In South Africa,
as elsewhere, each company pursues its business interests independently. To
interweave the two despite several clear statements of these facts is nothing
more than sloppy
journalism."
There "is a world
of difference" between corruption and buying a car at a discount, the
statement said.
Sexwale on Monday
released a statement admitting that he purchased a car through DaimlerChrysler
Aerospace at a discount.
DCSA spokeswoman
Lulama Chakela said DaimlerChrysler Aerospace became extinct in 1999.
"This discount is
something to which we are entitled, and would have insisted upon. We are aware
DaimlerChrysler Aerospace has now been absorbed into EADS. At no stage did we
have any dealings with EADS.
"We therefore
view the attempt to link this genuine and legitimate purchase to the
controversial arms transaction as mischief making and ridiculous."
The Democratic
Alliance on Monday said EADS owed the country an explanation regarding its role
in providing luxury cars to "VIP's".
DA public accounts
spokeswoman Raenette Taljaard said it was with a "great degree of relief
that we note the names of the arms deal VIPs".
"The DA has
called for these names since the Yengeni scandal broke. But the fact remains
that EADS acted as a discount car dealership during a crucial procurement
negotiation for South Africa's Strategic Defence Procurement," Taljaard
said.
She said EADS's
commercial reputation was at stake and the company owed the South African
public, and its own shareholders, a clear explanation why it entered the car
selling business if it did not wish to influence key players in the defence
procurement.
The United Democratic
Movement said the published list of names further pressurised the already taxed
team of investigators probing the arms deal.
UDM public accounts
spokesman Gerhard Koornhof said the fact that the individuals named interacted
with an arms supplier to acquire their vehicles unavoidably begged the question
as to whether or not bribery was the main instigating factor.
The UDM was concerned
that it seemed that not only politicians were involved, but also bureaucrats.
Of "special
concern" was the implication of EADS managing director Michael Woerfel, who
acquired four vehicles from sister company DaimlerChrysler, and had not
adequately explained whom they were given to, Koornhof said.
"Furthermore, new
names are being revealed and this raises the question about who they are and
what their roles were in the arms acquisition."
The arms deal is being
investigated by the Auditor-General, the Public Protector and the National
Director of Public Prosecutions.
Meanwhile, the
Department of Trade and Industry on Monday issued a statement on media reports
regarding Vanan Pillay, the previous director of the department's national
industrial participation programme.
It reacted to a report
in the Sunday Times newspaper a week ago which stated that he bought an E-class
Mercedes Benz through EADS at a discounted price.
Pillay said the
vehicle was purchased through the government motor finance scheme. He said the
transaction was reported to the department's human resources division and that
the details were on file.
"On Tuesday, 26
June Mr Pillay lodged a submission with the department disclosing the purchase
of the Mercedes C250 TD valued at R196000 for which he paid R141000 in July 1999
from Daimler-Chrysler Aerospace (now EADS). In his view, this constituted a full
disclosure," the statement said.
"The
Director General has launched a preliminary internal investigation to verify Mr
Pillay's statements... The facts established by this exercise will determine the
next course of
action, and the department will make public the findings of this exercise."
With
acknowledgement to Sapa and Business Day.