Corrupt Arms Deals Report will Light Fuses |
Publication | Sunday Independent |
Date | 2000-09-16 |
Reporter | Sam Sole |
Web Link | www.iol.co.za |
Months of investigation by the auditor-general's office into the terms and
procedures of South Africa's complex arms deals will culminate in the
tabling of a 10-page document in parliament this week. While it is
understood the report is not explosive, it is set to light the fuse for some big bangs.
According to a defence ministry source, the auditor-general has recommended
a more detailed investigation - via a forensic audit or special
investigation - of the sub-contracts which fell outside his original terms of reference.
It is some of these sub-contracts - between foreign contractors and local
defence suppliers - that have attracted most of the allegations of
corruption that have dogged the controversial acquisition process.
Among the key areas believed to have been dealt with is the decision, late
in the tender process, to move the goalposts on the bidding for a
fighter-trainer - a contract which eventually went to British Aerospace's
Hawk trainer.
'The auditor-general was not satisfied with such explanations'
Defence industry sources say that "one value system" was agreed for the
technical evaluation of all defence acquisition programmes - the trainers, the advanced fighter, the corvettes, the submarines and the helicopters.
Essentially, all other things being equal, price was to be the crucial
factor.
When it became clear that the Italian ND339 trainer would have to be
recommended, the ministry of defence, with cabinet approval, downgraded the
price factor for this programme.
According to Helmoed Heitman of Jane's Defence Weekly, there were good reasons for moving the goalposts
on the trainer. "The ND339 is cheap, but
it's old technology. Essentially, it's an Impala with a new nose. Also it
has a straight wing, rather than a swept wing - which is a disadvantage for
training for the advanced fighter."
But it is clear that the auditor-general was not satisfied with such
explanations.
Mosiuoa Lekota, the defence minister, could not be reached for comment, but
a source close to the ministry said: "The auditor-general's report has not yielded anything new. It found the integrity of process at a
government to
government level cannot be questioned. However, lower down, at the sub-contract level, there
are things that can still be investigated."
With acknowledgement to Sam Sole and the Sunday Independent.