Mbeki to Order New Unit to Probe R43 bn Arms Deal? |
Publication | News24 |
Date | 2001-02-02 |
Reporter | Sapa |
Web Link |
Pretoria - President
Thabo Mbeki would consider appointing a special investigating unit (SIU) if this
was needed to probe South Africa's R43 billion arms deal, the presidency said on
Thursday.
"There is
absolutely no problem with considering the involvement of an SIU at an
appropriate time," presidential legal advisor Mojanku Gumbi told reporters
in Pretoria.
Political observers
have interpreted the move as a bid to appease public concern following Mbeki's
decision to exclude the unit headed by Judge Willem Heath from the probe.
In another new
development on Friday, SABC news reported that the ANC has called on the
government to probe Judge Heath following the interception of letter from Pan
Africanist Congress MP Patricia de Lille to Judge Heath calling on him not to
supply information and documents to President Thabo Mbeki as requested.
Friday is also the
deadline given by De Lille to Mbeki for him to supply reasons why Judge Heath
was excluded from the arms deal probe.
Mbeki's lawyers
confirmed on Thursday that the information would be supplied but warned that
"it could take some time."
Discussing what she
regarded as " an appropriate time" for the establishment of a new
special unit, Gumbi said this would be after the amendment of the Act governing
SIUs and provided that prima facie evidence of wrongdoing in the arms deal had
emerged by that stage.
"If the
investigation is still on and there is a need for that kind of power and skill,
the president will certainly consider that."
Gumbi reiterated that
sufficient information was required for a proclamation to be issued that would
enable the appointment of an SIU.
She and
Director-General in the Presidency Frank Chikane were briefing reporters about
the government's stance on demands for a multi-agency probe into allegations of
corruption in the arms deal.
Parliament's watchdog
public accounts committee last year called for such an inquiry to be conducted
by the SIU headed by Judge Willem Heath, the Auditor-General, the Public
Protector, and the Investigating Directorate: Serious Economic Offences.
Mbeki on January 19
announced that the Heath unit would be excluded from the investigation.
In a televised address
he cited a Constitutional Court ruling that it was unconstitutional for a judge
to head the unit. Mbeki added there was not sufficient information to justify a
proclamation for the unit to conduct a probe.
Mbeki quoted two
senior advocates, Heath unit investigator Jan Lubbe, and Western Cape Director
of Prosecutions Frank Kahn, to support his contention that a proclamation was
not justified.
They agreed that there
was no prima facie evidence that a criminal offence had been committed in the
arms deal, Mbeki said.
It has since emerged
that both advocates also told Mbeki that they agreed with the public accounts
committee that an investigation by an SIU into the arms deal was warranted.
This was not mentioned
by Mbeki in his televised address, prompting accusations that he had misled the
public.
Chikane and Gumbi on
Thursday denied these assertions, saying Mbeki had referred to the two advocates
only with regard to the availability of prima facie evidence.
Gumbi contended that
the two advocates had also foreseen a legal problem with the appointment of an
SIU in view of the Constitutional Court ruling.
Hence their proposal
that an acting judge be appointed to head the unit until legislation was amended
to accommodate the Constitutional Court ruling, Gumbi said.
The two advocates
argued that an acting judge could revert to his personal status once a new SIU
Act was in place. This would ensure continuity should the unit be involved in
the probe from the start, they said.
Gumbi on Thursday
cited this proposal as evidence that the two advocates also recognised there was
a legal problem with the appointment of an SIU.
Chikane rejected
criticism that Mbeki had not applied his mind to the recommendation of the two
advocates.
"I'm saying he
did apply his mind, because I was there," he said.
Chikane confirmed that
a preliminary investigation by the three other investigation agencies was
underway to determine whether prima facie evidence of wrongdoing existed.
The result of this
inquiry would determine government's further course of action, Chikane said.
Cabinet on Wednesday
approved a draft Bill providing for an individual other than a judge to head the
SIU. It would be tabled in Parliament as soon as possible, the Justice Ministry
said.
With acknowledgement to News24.