Witch-Hunt for Whistleblowers |
Publication | Mail & Guardian |
Date | 2002-03-15 |
Reporter | Paul Kirk, Stefaans Brümmer |
Web Link | www.mg.co.za |
Auditor-General Shauket Fakie's hunt for
government employees or contractors who leaked details of the arms deal
investigation intensified this week with confirmation that former judge Willem
Heath was to be interviewed on Friday.
Fakie confirmed he was overseeing a probe into who had leaked information
to M&G writer Paul Kirk for an article published on January 11. The article
stated that information available to investigators - on gifts received by a
senior naval officer or his relatives from a winning tenderer - had not made it
into the final report on the R50 billion-plus arms deal.
Fakie also confirmed a separate probe under his authority, into the leak of
confidential "working papers" to an outside party whom he did
not specify, but who was "not from the media". In this case
members of the special investigating unit, formerly headed by Heath, were under
the spotlight.
The Freedom of Expression Institute (FXI) this week branded Fakie's probe
into the leak to M&G a "serious blow to transparency in government".
Fakie, however, denied he had embark on a witch-hunt and said: "I am not
opposed to transparency and openness at all ... But this probe relates to
information [contained in] working papers and classified information."
Members of Fakie's own office have pointed out that information was hardly kept
secure - having been stored for months in a pantry.
Fakie said he had a duty to ensure his office's code of conduct was upheld, and
confirmed that 25 people - contractors and employees of his office and the two
other agencies that made up the joint investigative team into the arms deal, the
offices of the public protector and the national director of public prosecutions
- had been identified as potential leaks. All 25, whom he said included himself,
had agreed to sign affidavits.
Signatories are asked to specify in the affidavits any contact they had with
Kirk before January 11 and also whether they object being subjected to lie
detector tests and having their office and private phone records examined.
Signatories are also asked to betray anyone they think "may have
communicated with the media" - which one arms investigator this week
described as "distasteful".
Fakie said the probe, which would have "minimal" cost
implications for his office, was being conducted by one staff member and "an
external person". He would not be drawn on whether the police, an
intelligence agency or any private agency was assisting.
Heath's representative Alan Phillips told the M&G that the former head of
the unit had approached Fakie to ask whether he was under investigation for the
leaks after he heard rumours he was suspected of leaking information. Heath and
the unit he formerly led did a preliminary investigation into the arms deal, but
were later excluded from the joint investigation.
Phillips said Fakie had assured Heath he was not a suspect. However, the M&G
has been informed that investigators will interview Heath.
On joining the office of the auditor general, staff are required to sign oaths
of secrecy. The same oath is signed by contractors, meaning that anyone caught
having leaked information could be criminally prosecuted.
FXI communications officer Scotch Tagwireyi said: "The action ... has
implications on the free flow of information, which is a cornerstone of
democracy."
With acknowledgements to Paul Kirk, Stefaans Brümmer and the Mail & Guardian.