Publication: Richard Young Issued: Date: 2006-11-22 Reporter: Richard Young Reporter:

A Short and Incomplete History of the Phrase "Generally Corrupt"

 

Publication 

Richard Young

Date 2006-11-22

 

Edmund Burke
Philosopher
1777
"Among a people generally corrupt, liberty cannot long exist"

Sam Sole
Journalist
18 February 2003
"I think the nature of the story also had so many compelling journalistic features. Arms purchases are always controversial and generally corrupt."

Tania Broughton
Journalist
25 October 2004
"The State wants to prove that, in fact, the pair had a generally corrupt relationship and that Shaik and his companies paid Zuma in return for business influence."

Tania Broughton
Journalist
26 October 2004
"The charges relate to a "generally corrupt" relationship between them, with Shaik and his Nkobi group of companies making payments amounting to R1.2 million to Zuma in return for business influence."

Tania Broughton
Journalist
28 October 2004
"In total, the state claims, Shaik paid Zuma R1.2 million in what the state says was a generally corrupt relationship between them."

Tania Broughton
Journalist
30 October 2004
"Shaik is accused of two counts of corruption and one of fraud. A corruption charge relates to what the state alleges was a generally corrupt relationship between the two men, the one paying the other for business influence."

SAPA
News Gathering Agency
5 November 2004
"The State contends there was a "generally corrupt" relationship between Zuma and Shaik. It alleges that Shaik and his Nkobi Holdings had paid at least R1.2 million to or on behalf of Zuma."

Paddy Harper
Journalist
14 November 2004
"The state argues that Shaik’s collective payment of R1,2-million to Zuma and on his behalf constituted a “generally corrupt” relationship between the two former comrades-in-arms."

William John Downer SC
Advocate and Prosecutor
25 April 2005
"So what we have here, M'Lord, I submit, is an essentially generally corrupt relationship and we don't, at this stage, have any particular payment being related to any particular action, as" ...[intervention]

And in response to the latter :

Hilary Squires
Judge of the High Court
25 April 2005
"Are you saying this corrupt design arose then even before 1995? [bold emphasis added]

With acknowledgement to Richard Young.