The Editor's Notebook |
Publication |
Business Day |
Date | 2008-01-21 |
Reporter | Peter Bruce |
Web Link | www.bday.co.za |
Someone,
Churchill I think, once said that if there was cricket in Heaven then he would
pray for rain when he died. He should have been in SA this past month. The grass
and the hills are green. The cows and sheep are fat. The dams are full. Good
rains and healthy harvests and animals mean that the political and economic
crises we are in have less of an impact than they might. The centre holds. High
interest rates, a failure to generate sufficient electricity and the absence of
national, provincial and, in many cases, local leadership have dented but not
broken spirits.
But we are being tested in ways we could not have
imagined just a year ago. Would the power cuts really be this bad? Would you
really have to pay double your bond? Would the president
really have tried to protect a suspected criminal?
It isn't his
defeat at Polokwane that has made Thabo Mbeki irrelevant. It's his betrayal of the trust of people who might otherwise have
looked to him for leadership about how best to see in the coming presidency of
Jacob Zuma and his camp.
To call into question, as Mbeki did, the
"appropriateness" in office of suspended NPA boss Vusi Pikoli for declining to
consult a flaky minister about arresting the national chief of police while
finding nothing inappropriate about Jackie Selebi's public friendship with a
gangster was breathtakingly poor judgment. Mbeki
bet his integrity on retaining leadership of the ANC, but he has now lost
both.
Jacob Zuma is a different kettle of
fish. Leadership hasn't been handed him on a plate. He was no one's
favourite in exile. He has endured arguably the worst press of any public figure
anywhere in the world for the past seven years. He is almost impossible to
defame. Yet even though he is only party leader and faces trial (and probable
conviction on some counts) for fraud and racketeering and corruption later this
year, the stability of the country rests with him.
It is a terrible
burden and we can take more comfort than fright out of the fact that Zuma has
embedded himself in the party. Sure, there are some dodgy characters in the
"structures" but there are some smart and honourable ones too. And they have a
voice, unlike, it is now apparent, the structures did under Mbeki.
The
consequences of that are all too apparent in areas like AIDS and crime, but let
us not get too carried away by his economic record either. To have averaged 5%
GDP growth during the greatest commodity prices boom in history is not that
impressive. And while Mbeki broke with economic convention to make this a
"developmental state", all that happened is that decisions got delayed (Eskom),
the cost of doing business here rose (Eskom, Telkom), and corruption deepened
(an ANC front company lands a huge contract to build one of Eskom's power
stations!).
The lessons for Zuma of recent events are many, but some are
more important than others:
First, sir, a progressive government need not
control the economy. Governments that try hardly ever succeed. Don't be seduced
by the odd success. Privatise everything. Give it all to the unions if you must,
as long as competition is encouraged. The job of a progressive government must
surely be the distribution and not the creation of wealth.
Second,
beware of men bearing gifts. Stop the gift thing now.
Make it an offence for any public or party official to get
any gift whatsoever.
Third, fund political parties openly out of
the public purse.
Fourth, consider the merits of a
plea bargain on the charges you face *1. We can't have you going to jail
*2.
Fifth, reconsider the party decision to disband the Scorpions.
It looks bad for you *3, given that they have
investigated you, and these people are a good advertisement for SA and the ANC.
Disbanding them now would look like an act of political revenge, which would be
foolish. There is a strong case for an independent prosecutions body with its
own investigative capability. There is no logical case for not having one. Both
the NPA and the police could fall under the justice ministry. Find a strong
candidate to run it.
THIS column returns and will appear every Monday.
Thanks, meanwhile, for putting up with a much-reduced newspaper over the
holidays. Just a few more days now and we'll be back to normal.
With acknowledgements to Peter Bruce and Business Day.