Publication: Business Day Issued: Date: 2008-09-22 Reporter: Karima Brown Reporter: Amy Musgrave Reporter: Hajra Omarjee

Defiant to Bitter End, Mbeki: 'I Did Not Meddle'

 

Publication 

Business Day

Date 2008-09-22
Reporter Karima Brown, Amy Musgrave,
Hajra Omarjee
Web Link www.bday.co.za

 

In a final swipe at his accusers, President Thabo Mbeki last night absolved himself and his government of ever interfering in the work of the National Prosecuting Authority (NPA) and the criminal justice system *1.

Mbeki's comments in his farewell speech to the nation follow the African National Congress's (ANC's) decision at the weekend to recall him before his term ended.

"I would like to restate the position of cabinet on the inferences made by the Honourable Judge Chris Nicholson that the president and cabinet have interfered in the work of the National Prosecuting Authority.

"Again I would like to state this categorically that we have never done this, and therefore never compromised the right of the National Prosecuting Authority to decide whom it wished to prosecute or not to prosecute," he said last night.

Mbeki said the same applied to the matter relating to ANC president Jacob Zuma.

"This applies equally to the painful matter relating to the court proceedings against the president of the ANC, Comrade Jacob Zuma."

Nicholson threw out the state's seven-year corruption and fraud case against Zuma earlier this month, saying that Zuma should have been given the right to make representations to the NPA before being charged again.

He also said there was executive meddling in the NPA's case against Zuma, and his long-held claims of a political conspiracy were not farfetched.

Nicholson noted a "distressing pattern" of "political interference, pressure or influence".

"It is a matter of grave concern that this process has taken place in the new SA, given the ravages it caused under the apartheid order," he said.

Nicholson cited the suspension of NPA boss Vusi Pikoli as an example of executive meddling. "All that is clear from the constitution, the National Prosecuting Authority Act and the various prosecution policies, directives and codes of conduct. The suspension of the national director was a most ominous move that struck at the core of a crucial state institution," he said in his judgment.

Mbeki's emphatic denial is in sharp contrast to evidence given by Pikoli in his version of events, which is the subject of an inquiry. Pikoli argued that he was suspended by Mbeki because of the NPA's investigation of suspended police chief Jackie Selebi.

Former National Assembly speaker Frene Ginwala, who is heading the inquiry, is yet to make a finding on the matter.

Last night's address came after much speculation that Mbeki's supporters in the cabinet would resign in solidarity, but Mbeki made no mention of this. He met the cabinet earlier in the day.

The 66-year-old Mbeki said on live television that he had handed a letter of resignation to Mbete yesterday.

The effective date of the resignation would be determined by the National Assembly.

"I have been a loyal member of the African National Congress for 52 years. I remain a member of the ANC and therefore respect its decisions. It is for this reason that I have taken the decision to resign as president of the republic, following the decision of the national executive committee of the ANC," he said.

Mbeki, who showed no emotion *2, listed the achievements of the government under his stewardship. These included the longest period of sustained growth thus far, the empowerment of women, winning the right to host the 2010 Soccer World Cup and becoming a non-permanent member of the United Nations Security Council.

However, he also acknowledged the "challenges" facing the country, including poverty, crime and corruption. "Despite the economic advances we have made, I would be the first to say that even as we ensured consistent economic growth, the fruits of these positive results are still to be fully and equitably shared among our people, hence the abject poverty we still find coexisting side by side with extraordinary opulence," he said.

Mbeki took the opportunity to thank the many who had sent him messages of support as well as his colleagues, and heads of state.

Democratic Alliance leader Helen Zille described Mbeki's resignation as "dignified", saying he used the opportunity to spell out the points of his presidency for which he wished to be remembered.

She said Mbeki demonstrated respect for Nicholson's judgment, even though he had not been given a chance to state his case in court.

Mbeki's dignified exit *3 gave the country hope that there would be some continuity in government between now and next year's election, Zille said.

Related Links

With acknowledgements to Karima Brown, Amy Musgrave, Hajra Omarjee and Business Day.



*1       Ngcuka and Maduna certainly obstructed the course of justice by not prosecuting Zuma in 2003.

It is impossible to think that this decision was made on their own accord.

It was clearly done to protect others involved in Arms Deal corruption by making a deal with Zuma who would have implicated them.

Highest among these others is Mbeki and it is logical that he, Ngcuka and Maduna interfered with the NPA in order not to charge Zuma.

But thus far there is no proof.

If there was any documentary evidence it will surely be long gone.

The only proof would come from affidavits under oath from Ngcuka and Maduna, but so far they have held on, at least in public.

Therefore the ANC could not have forced Mbeki to resign based on this allegation.

The logic is therefore very strong that the ANC was able to use some other reason to force Mbeki to resign.

Where there is a veritable mountain of court-quality documentary evidence against Mbeki is that regarding his interference in the corvette combat suite component of the  Arms Deal where he clearly was dealing for Thomson-CSF and all the indicators are that Thomson-CSF paid R300 million (199 Rands] of bribes to get its lion's share, without any competition, at an inflated price and with Mbeki's assistance.

The ANC has of late been gathering such evidence and my educated guess is that they have threatened to get him charged for corruption on the Arms Deal.


*2*3    At the same time, for the last two to three months there have been indicators that Mbeki and Zuma have been concocting a deal which gets them both off the hook in a dignified kind of way.

The overall principle behind such a deal is called MAD - Mutually Assured Destruction.

Tell me it ain't so.

If my friend Bheki Jacobs was not dead I would know more.

Tell me it ain't so.