South Africa’s Last Chance |
Publication |
New York Times |
Date | 2009-04-13 |
Reporter | Johann Rossouw |
Web Link |
Pretoria, South Africa Every year in December and January the summer
holidays South Africa practically comes to a standstill. The small but growing
middle class heads for the country’s glorious beaches; poorer people join the
exodus from the cities to visit family in the rural areas.
People returning from holidays this year were greeted with huge billboards
filled with the smiling face of Jacob Zuma, who is likely to be South Africa’s
next president. Mr. Zuma is a man who tells different factions what they want to
hear, but whose real positions are still unclear.
One of the ironies of the approaching elections is that they are a sideshow to
the real election, which saw Mr. Zuma become president of the African National
Congress at its national conference in December 2007. While the A.N.C.’s victory
in elections next week is a foregone conclusion, the battle to become president
of the A.N.C. was a much more uncertain affair.
That battle brought an end to Thabo Mbeki’s term as A.N.C. president. But the
real victory belonged to the A.N.C.’s two so-called partners, the Congress of
South African Trade Unions, or Cosatu, and the South African Communist Party.
Mr. Zuma’s victory was really that of Cosatu and the Communists, who never
forgave Mr. Mbeki for the way they were sidelined from policy-making in 1996. It
was at that time that Mr. Mbeki and his inner circle, under the pressure from
South Africa’s leading companies, adopted the neo-liberal Growth, Employment and
Redistribution economic policy. This was done without serious consultation with
the broader A.N.C.
Cosatu and the Communists have never had the courage to independently contest a
parliamentary election. They have opted for a different strategy: Rather than
confront your enemy, infiltrate and take control of him.
This strategy paid off at the A.N.C. conference in December 2007. The Mbeki camp
had fallen out of touch with the grievances of ordinary South Africans and the
poor. Cosatu and the Communists mobilized them to support Mr. Zuma.
The brilliance of Mr. Zuma’s campaign to become A.N.C. president was to mobilize
all the various factions who had over the years been alienated by Mr. Mbeki. In
addition to Cosatu, the Communists, these included the militant A.N.C. Youth
League, the new black billionaires and middle class and traditional leaders.
Obviously this coalition couldn’t hold together unless Mr. Zuma could inspire
them with a new vision. Now, Mr. Zuma might be many things, but he is certainly
not a visionary. And so, by the time that Mr. Mbeki was deposed by his own party
in August, two realities became clear.
The first was that it seemed very little could stop Mr. Zuma from becoming
president. The second was that the A.N.C. had become a deeply sclerotic party,
held together by the access to state and private
patronage. As for a future vision for South Africa, very little remains.
For while all these power struggles were being fought, more danger signs for
South Africa began flashing. The first was the growing disjunction between
economic growth and social development. While South Africa has been able to
achieve consistent growth in GDP of 3 percent or higher for most years since
1994, the country fell in the U.N. Human Development Index from position 89 in
1998 to 125 in 2008.
In public education, health and services things
have gone from bad to worse. Despite one of the highest per capita
education budgets in the world, South African school children have one of the
world’s lowest literacy rates. In last
year’s final year exam, which was the first to be taken by the children who went
through 12 years of so-called outcomes-based education, the pass rate was not
significantly higher than at the end of apartheid in 1994.
When it comes to public health, most of the nine provinces, especially in poor
rural areas, are struggling to fill staff positions. According to media
accounts, the most recent Saving Babies report states that of the 8,000 babies
who died at birth in 2007 in state hospitals, 44 percent of the deaths may be
ascribed to poor care.
Johann Rossouw is a South African philosopher and political commentator. This
article first appeared in Le Monde diplomatique. Distributed by Agence Global.
With acknowledgements to
Johann Rossouw and New York Times.