Publication: Cape Argus Issued: Date: 2009-03-10 Reporter: Louise Flanagan Reporter: Angela Quintal Reporter: Solly Maphumulo

Questions Linger over Shaik

 

Publication 

Cape Argus

Date

2009-03-10

Reporter Louise Flanagan, Angela Quintal,
Solly Maphumulo

Web Link

www.capeargus.co.za



As the KwaZulu-Natal medical authorities launched an all-out offensive to show that paroled fraudster Schabir Shaik is critically ill, a number of unanswered questions continue to fuel the controversy over his release.

A week after the parole decision was revealed to the public, prison and health authorities have still not answered:

• Who were the three medical experts who completed the report upon which the parole decision was based?

• Did all three of these experts conclude that Shaik's illness was "terminal" and that he was "in the final phase" of that illness? If not, what are the names and qualifications of those who said he was dying?

These are the requirements which must be met, in terms of the law, before medical parole is considered for a convicted prisoner.

Why has this medical submission to the parole board not been made public? The reason given was that the document contained personal, confidential information.

But there is nothing to stop the department from releasing the names of the medical experts who recommended he be paroled.

Added to that Shaik's brother, Moe, has given long and detailed information about his medical condition. Presumably this has been done with the permission of Shaik.

The document released on Monday revealed that the cardiologist who reportedly told hospital authorities that Shaik should be discharged also recommended last year that the fraudster be considered for medical parole.

Read the full story in the print edition of The Star today.

Related Articles

With acknowledgements to Louise Flanagan, Angela Quintal, Solly Maphumulo and Cape Argus.