Arms deal:
Shrinking legal team impairs probe |
Publication |
Mail & Guardian |
Date | 2013-11-22 |
Reporter |
Glynnis Underhill |
Web link | www.mg.co.za |
The arms deal commission's commitment to
investigating criminal liability is
being questioned after axings.
The Arms Procurement Commission has
failed to renew the contracts of its
internal legal team tasked with the next
phase of identifying those criminally
liable in the arms deal investigation.
The move by the commission to axe six
skilled legal staffers who would have
undertaken this critical phase has
dented its credibility, say former team
members.
This phase of the commission would
identify who will be called to give
evidence at the public hearings.
"The staff would need to be around for
this part of the hearings," said a
former legal staff member. "It points to
the fact that they won't be looking at
criminal wrongdoing."
In a memo issued to staff by the
chairperson of the commission, Judge
Willie Seriti, in January this year, he
stated that criminal aspects of the
investigation would be the "second
phase" of the public hearings. The
internal legal team would tackle this
task, he wrote.
The commission's internal legal team,
which once consisted of 10 people, now
consists of two legal members and a
research assistant who is studying law.
Second agenda
Three senior legal figures –
commissioner Judge Francis Legodi;
senior investigator and respected
attorney Mokgale Norman Moabi; and
principal legal researcher attorney Kate
Painting – also quit their jobs at the
commission in the past year.
Moabi said in his resignation letter
that there was a "second agenda" running
at the commission in addition to its
mandate to unravel the truth of the 1999
arms deal. The purported second agenda
is said to be the protection of ANC
officials and others implicated in the
corruption scandal, including President
Jacob Zuma.
Moabi was clearly not surprised by the
developments at the commission. "Those
whose contracts are not renewed … their
time is up, and they know that they have
not been part of the core team," he told
the Mail & Guardian this week.
Fanyana Mdumbe, described as an
"academic" advocate by colleagues
because he has not done his pupillage,
remains at the commission.
As head of the legal team, Mdumbe is
said to maintain tight control over all
the evidence and investigations, and to
brief evidence leaders.
The only remaining legal investigator is
attorney Riena Charles, who returned to
work at the commission nine years after
she was acquitted on fraud and
corruption charges.
Lifespan
"Why would you fire people who were
investigating the second phase? We were
meant to look at those who might have
taken money, which is the crux of the
investigation," said a former team
staffer, who asked not to be named.
Although some former legal staff told
the M&G they sometimes found it
difficult to obtain evidence to work on
at the commission, they still hoped they
would succeed in unravelling the truth
behind the R70-billion arms deal.
The documents manager, who was a legal
professional, has also been given
notice, and her role has been taken over
by Samkelo Hlatshwayo, who is said to be
related by marriage to Seriti. The
commission has refused to deny or
confirm she is his wife's niece.
The commission has now had its lifespan
extended to November 2014, with a
further six months to complete its
report. It has allegedly asked for
another R20-million to complete its
work, but this could not be confirmed by
commission spokesperson William Baloyi.
Baloyi said one of the main reasons for
cutting staff, apart from cost- cutting,
was that a massive amount of
documentation received from state
departments on the Strategic Defence
Procurement Package had been analysed
and completed.
This claim is disputed by a former legal
staff member. "That's not true. Who
analysed it? The only question you have
to ask yourself is how [they]can carry
out [their] mandate without the
investigators."
With acknowledgement to Glynnis Underhill and Mail & Guardian.
This is not
a job, it is a game, an expensive game,
called kick for touch.
It is also an opportunity for number 1
to get back at his erstwhile humiliators,
all the time his involvement being
ringfenced by his appointed, sorry
anointed, gatekeepers.
But what will the APC do when confronted
with incontrovertible documentation
providing clear evidence of corruption
of major role players and equitable
payments by the foreign armaments
suppliers?
And whatever way, whenever when, it will
out.
The anointed ones may well taste the sip
of this poisoned chalice.
At the same time the lambs might feel
the snip of sharp steel at the altar of
public duty.
Never a dull moment in Africa,
especially southern Africa.
So gaan die lewe.